Comparison of provisions related to serious mental illness in adults
in the Helping Families in Mental Health Crisis Act (HR 3717) and in the
Strengthening Mental Illness in our Communities Act (HR 4574)
(Draft 5/21/14 based on initial analysis. Prepared by Mental Illness Policy Org.)
PDF VERSION HERE
|
Helping Families in Mental Health Crisis Act (HR-3717) |
Strengthening Mental Health in Our Communities (HR-4574) |
Sponsor Co-sponsors |
Tim Murphy 62 Republican |
Ron Barber 44 Democrat |
Starts to address hospital bed shortage that prevents seriously ill from getting care when needed |
Yes |
No |
Provides funds for Assisted Outpatient Treatment Pilot Programs (last off ramp before jail). |
Yes |
No |
Gives states incentive to implement need for treatment/grave disability standards so mentally ill loved ones can be treated before becoming danger to self or others. |
Yes |
No |
Writes exceptions into HIPAA/FERPA so parents can get information about diagnosis, what prescriptions need filling, and pending appointments of their loved ones to help them |
Yes |
No |
Funds NIMH research into reducing violence by untreated seriously mentally ill |
Yes |
No |
Requires government to prioritize the most seriously ill rather than least ill |
Yes |
No |
Inhibits SAMHSA from giving grants to non-evidenced based programs and funding anti-treatment advocacy (ex. eliminating hospitals, banning ECT, opposing AOT…) |
Yes |
No |
Inhibits PAIMII from overruling parents involved in care of loved ones |
Yes |
No |
Focuses on medical model of treatment |
Yes |
No |
Gives law enforcement and people with a medical background an important role on advisory boards |
Yes |
No |
Cuts funding of programs that are not working |
Yes |
No |
Eliminate the 190 day lifetime limit |
No |
Yes |
Reauthorizes Garrett Lee Suicide Programs |
Yes |
Yes |
Support for Mental Health Courts |
Yes |
Yes |
Train police to handle mental illness calls better |
Yes |
Yes |
Protects Classes of medicines |
Yes |
Yes |
Increases data collected by DOJ on mental illness |
Yes |
Yes |